It is the middle of November, about a month before finals. Your daughter calls from school and says she is “a little behind” in two classes, which you have learned means more than a little. Or you are the student, two grades sliding, wondering whether free tutoring, your college’s coaching, or a paid academic coach for college students is worth the time you don’t have.

The first instinct is a tutor. Sometimes that is right. Often the student understands the material and still is not doing the work, and no amount of re-explaining touches that. This post sorts out what each kind of help actually does. The first half is written to parents. The second half is for the student.


Is it the material, or everything around the material?

Tutoring answers one question: does your student understand the content? If they work the problem set honestly and still get lost, a tutor is the right tool.

Most of what goes wrong in a college semester is not that. The paper is open on the laptop for an hour and nothing gets written. The exam is a surprise two days out, because nothing lives in a calendar. The professor’s emails go unanswered, and the class they are failing is the one they stopped attending. Bedtime has drifted to 3 a.m. Or the worry is louder than the work: they know the material and freeze on the exam.

None of that is a tutor’s job. Starting, planning, and avoidance are skill and habit problems, and that is where coaching works. Persistent anxiety, low mood, or sleep that has fallen apart should go to a doctor or the campus counseling center first. If attention has been a struggle since childhood and was never evaluated, that is worth doing; the National Institute of Mental Health notes that ADHD symptoms usually continue into adulthood and can interfere with school.

THE KEY INSIGHT

Tutoring is for “I don’t understand this.” Coaching is for “I understand it, and I’m still not doing it.” In our experience, most students who are behind a month before finals are in the second group, and the help they reach for first was built for the first group.


Academic coaching vs tutoring, and three other kinds of help

A struggling college student can use five kinds of support. They do different jobs, and several work well together.

1 Tutoring: help with the content

A tutor re-teaches the material: the chemistry mechanism, the proof, the essay’s argument. Most colleges offer it free; CU Boulder’s options include the Writing Center and the Math Academic Resource Center. Use it for one gap in one class. It cannot help a student who is not opening the book.

2 The college’s own academic coaching

Many colleges now have coaches who work on the layer under the content. At CU Boulder, academic coaching is free for every Arts and Sciences undergraduate, covering procrastination, time management, study strategies, and exam prep, and engineering advising offers the same to engineering undergrads. It is good, free, and the first place to go. The limit: the student has to book it, keep it, and carry the rest of the week alone.

3 Disability services and accommodations

If your student has ADHD, a learning disability, or another documented condition, disability services can approve adjustments such as extended testing time or a reduced course load. That is access, not tutoring. Some offices add more: CU Boulder’s Disability Services offers free peer academic coaching to undergraduates who are registered with the office and approved for at least one accommodation.

4 An outside academic or executive function coach

A private coach does what campus coaching does, more often and with more follow-up: a weekly plan, check-ins between sessions, someone who notices on Wednesday that Friday’s paper has not started. The field is unregulated, so ask about training and supervision. Our post on executive function coaching for young adults covers what it involves.

5 Mentoring

A mentor works on the whole week, not only the coursework: sleep, the job, the friends, the reason any of it matters. When school trouble is tangled with drift or isolation, that wider view is what moves it.


What changes once your student is in college

This surprises parents. In high school, the school found your child, wrote the plan, and called you. In college, almost all of it runs through the student.

The U.S. Department of Education is plain about this. IEPs do not apply in college. A student who wants accommodations has to identify themselves to the school and usually provide current documentation, and neither school has to pay for a new evaluation. CU Boulder’s Disability Services tells families the same: students register on their own, instructors talk with the student rather than the parent, and accommodations aim for equal access, not success. A student can sign a release that lets the office talk with you, but the student stays the main point of contact.

So the most useful thing you can do is not to call the dean. It is to help your son or daughter make the calls: register with disability services if there is a documented condition, request a campus coach, email the professor. Accommodations are not retroactive, which matters a month before finals. Sit beside them while they send the email. That is support. Sending it for them is not.


An accountability coach before college starts

Some parents start a year early. Your senior has coasted on being bright, and you have been the planner, the alarm clock, and the reminder system. You can already picture next fall.

Senior year is the time to build it, while you can still see how it goes. A coach or mentor works with your teen on what college will assume: a calendar they actually use, a weekly plan, starting assignments without you, emailing a teacher. The goal is less of you in the system by May, so the system is theirs by September. We wrote about why so many students come apart at exactly this handoff in ADHD in young adults after high school.


If you’re the student reading this

Maybe you searched for how to find an academic coach without your parents. You can. You are an adult, and the help on your campus is built to be asked for by you.

Start with what is free. Request an academic coach through your advising office; at CU Boulder that happens in Buff Portal Advising. If you have ADHD, a learning disability, or another documented condition and have not registered with disability services, do it this week, because accommodations do not reach back to exams that already happened. Use tutoring for the one class where you are actually lost on the content.

Then be honest about the pattern. If you understand the material and still are not doing it, that is not laziness. It is a starting problem, and starting problems get worse under pressure. Our post on procrastination in young adults looks at what the avoidance is doing. If things have gone further than two bad classes, such as probation or a withdrawal, our post on leaving college is written for parents, but the way back is the same for you.


When an academic coach for college students is worth paying for

Free campus coaching is good. A paid coach earns its cost when you have tried the free version and the problem is follow-through between sessions, when you need contact more than once a week, when school is tangled with sleep, gaming, substance use, or a life that has shrunk to your room, or when you are coming back from a leave and want the semester planned rather than improvised.

It is probably not worth it if you have not used your campus coach yet, or if the issue is one class’s content. Whether you bring your parents in is your call. Either way, the coach should be working on your goals, not reporting on you.

“You don’t need a new personality before finals. You need a plan for the next four weeks and someone who checks it with you.”

What to do this week, a month before finals

Put every exam, paper, and deadline through finals on one page. Next to each, write the day you will start it, not the day it is due. Then book one meeting this week: your campus coach, your professor’s office hours, or disability services. If you are the parent, your part this week is to ask what the plan is, and then let your student make it.


How Noble Mentors helps with academic coaching

Our academic coaching is not tutoring. When a student needs a tutor, we say so and help find one. We work on the layer underneath: one planning system the student will actually use, a weekly planning session, big assignments split into steps that can start today, and study methods like spaced practice and self-testing, practiced on real coursework, with test prep that starts ten days out instead of the night before.

Because it runs through mentoring, the same mentor pays attention to sleep, motivation, and what the student cares about. Mentoring is not therapy. If something looks clinical, such as untreated ADHD or anxiety, we say so and help find the right professional. Every plan is reviewed in case consultation with me and our Clinical Director, Joseph DeNicholas, LCSW. Lucian Davis, one of our mentors, grew up in Boulder and spent ten years as a wilderness therapy field guide and executive functioning coach.

The basics, plainly. Mentoring is private pay. Most families start with our Base Package, about two sessions a week. Once momentum is there, it steps down to one 90-minute session a week with text and call support between sessions. We go over rates on the free 40-minute call, and students are welcome to call us for themselves.


Questions people ask about an academic coach for college students

How do I find an academic coach for college on my own, without my parents?

Start at your college. Most offer academic coaching through advising or a learning center, and you request it yourself; ask your advisor. For an outside coach, reach out directly. Ask about training, supervision, how often you will be in contact, and cost.

Is a paid academic coach worth it if my college offers free coaching and tutoring?

Use the free help first. A paid coach makes sense when follow-through between sessions is still the problem, or when school is tangled with the rest of your life. For one class’s content, a tutor is the better tool, and often free.

Should I use disability services or hire a private executive function coach?

They do different jobs, so often both. Disability services approves accommodations like extended testing time; colleges are not required to provide personal services such as tutoring, though CU Boulder adds free peer coaching for approved students. A private coach builds planning and follow-through with more contact. Register with disability services early, since accommodations only apply going forward.

Can I get an accountability coach for my high school senior before college?

Yes, and senior year is a good time. The work is building the habits college assumes, such as a calendar, a weekly plan, and talking to teachers directly, while you are still close enough to see how it goes. At Noble Mentors this happens through one-on-one mentoring with academic coaching built in.

If you’re a parent and this sounds like your student’s semester, schedule a free 40-minute consultation and we’ll talk it through. If you’re the student, you can book the same call yourself. If we’re not the right fit, we’ll point you to who is.


Serving Colorado’s Front Range

We work with college students along the Front Range, CU Boulder students among them, and with the parents watching from a distance. Academic coaching happens in person, wherever the work actually gets done, with one mentor week to week.

We work with families and students in Boulder, Denver, and across the Boulder to Denver corridor, in person. Parent coaching and much of our mentoring are also available virtually anywhere in the country.

Based in Lafayette, CO. Schedule a free 40-minute consultation to talk through what support could look like for you or your family.

About the Author

James Farmer

James Farmer is the founder of Noble Mentors, a therapeutic mentoring organization along Colorado’s Front Range. With over 15 years of experience mentoring teens and young adults through pivotal transitions, James trains and supervises a team of mentors committed to transformation through genuine relationship. He believes that real growth happens not in an office, but in the actual terrain of a young person’s life.


Read next

Sober Holidays: Helping a Young Adult in Early Recovery Through Thanksgiving and Christmas

Sober holidays in early recovery: why Thanksgiving and Christmas are hard, how to build a plan with your young adult, and what to do if there is a slip.

Read the post →